In recent years, the Goods and Services Tax (GST) has transformed the Indian taxation landscape, providing a streamlined tax structure. However, like any system, it faces challenges, particularly with ensuring compliance. One such area of concern is the GST Composition Scheme (CLS), a simplified tax scheme designed to ease the burden on small businesses. The Comptroller and Auditor General (CAG) has raised red flags, urging the Finance Ministry to take decisive action against high-risk taxpayers who may be exploiting this scheme. Let's explore this issue in detail.

Understanding the GST Composition Scheme

The GST Composition Scheme is a simplified tax regime available to small taxpayers whose annual turnover does not exceed ₹1.5 crore. For those in special category states, this limit is set at ₹75 lakh. Under this scheme, eligible businesses pay a fixed percentage of their turnover as tax, making compliance easier and reducing their tax burden.

Why the GST Composition Scheme is Vital

For small businesses, the GST Composition Scheme is a lifeline. It reduces the complexity of tax compliance, allowing them to focus on their core business activities without getting bogged down by the intricacies of regular GST filings. However, the simplicity of the scheme also makes it susceptible to misuse.

CAG's Alarming Findings

The CAG, in its audit report, revealed that a significant number of taxpayers under the GST Composition Scheme are at high risk of exceeding the turnover threshold, which would disqualify them from the scheme. After analyzing data from 8.66 lakh composition taxpayers under central jurisdiction during the fiscal years 2019-20 to 2021-22, the CAG identified multiple instances where businesses might be under-declaring their 'value of outward supply' to remain eligible for the scheme.

Risk Areas Highlighted by CAG

The audit pointed out two major risk areas:

Under-Declaration of Outward Supply: Some taxpayers appear to be intentionally under-reporting their sales to stay within the turnover limit of the GST Composition Scheme. This under-declaration is a serious issue, as it not only leads to revenue loss for the government but also gives an unfair advantage to dishonest businesses over their compliant counterparts.

Failure to Meet Eligibility Criteria: The CAG found that many taxpayers continue to benefit from the Composition Scheme despite not meeting the eligibility requirements. This includes failing to file returns and pay taxes under the reverse charge mechanism, a key obligation for those under the scheme.

The Role of Third-Party Data in Identifying High-Risk Taxpayers

The CAG has recommended that the Finance Ministry employ a risk-based approach to regularly identify high-risk taxpayers. This involves verifying the declared sales figures of these taxpayers using additional sources, including third-party data such as Income Tax (IT) returns and the 'Vahan' database, which records vehicle registrations. By cross-referencing this data, the government can more accurately assess whether businesses are under-reporting their turnover to remain in the Composition Scheme.

The Importance of Regular Audits and Monitoring

Regular audits and monitoring are crucial in ensuring that the GST Composition Scheme serves its intended purpose. The CAG's findings underscore the need for the Finance Ministry to establish a robust system that can identify ineligible taxpayers and remove them from the scheme promptly. This will help prevent the misuse of the scheme and ensure that only those who genuinely qualify can benefit from it.

The Consequences of Non-Compliance

The CAG's report highlights the consequences of non-compliance, both for the government and for taxpayers. For the government, the primary concern is revenue loss. When businesses under-declare their sales, they contribute less tax than they should, leading to a shortfall in government revenue. For taxpayers, non-compliance can lead to penalties, fines, and even criminal charges in severe cases.

Recommendations by the CAG

To address these issues, the CAG has made several key recommendations:

Periodic Identification of High-Risk Taxpayers: The Finance Ministry should periodically identify high-risk taxpayers using a risk-based approach. This involves analyzing data from GST returns, third-party sources, and other relevant databases.

Verification of Declared Sales Figures: The Ministry should verify the declared sales figures of taxpayers using third-party data to ensure that they are not under-reporting their turnover to stay within the Composition Scheme.

Exclusion of Ineligible Taxpayers: The Ministry should take steps to exclude ineligible taxpayers from the Composition Scheme. This includes developing a system to identify and remove such taxpayers promptly.

The Role of Technology in Enhancing Compliance

Technology can play a significant role in enhancing compliance with the GST Composition Scheme. Advanced data analytics and artificial intelligence can help the government identify patterns of under-reporting and other forms of tax evasion. By leveraging technology, the Finance Ministry can ensure that the GST Composition Scheme remains a viable option for genuine small businesses while weeding out those who misuse it.

Ensuring Fairness in the GST Composition Scheme

The GST Composition Scheme is designed to simplify tax compliance for small businesses, but it must be fair. By implementing the CAG's recommendations, the government can ensure that the scheme is not abused by those looking to evade taxes. This will create a level playing field for all businesses and ensure that the benefits of the scheme reach those who truly need them.

Read More: India Post GDS Result 2024: Your Guide to the First Merit List Release and What Comes Next

Conclusion

The GST Composition Scheme is an essential tool for small businesses in India, offering them much-needed relief from the complexities of tax compliance. However, the findings of the CAG's audit report indicate that stricter oversight is necessary to prevent misuse. By regularly identifying and monitoring high-risk taxpayers, verifying their declared sales figures, and excluding ineligible taxpayers from the scheme, the Finance Ministry can safeguard the integrity of the GST Composition Scheme. This will ensure that the scheme continues to benefit the small businesses it was designed to support.